CASE HISTORIES OF THE USE OF INSECTS IN INVESTIGATIONS
Wayne D. Lord
Federal Bureau of Investigation, Washington, DC
THE IMPORTANCE OF BLOW FLIES: MAGGOTS, Cases 06-10
Maggots grow rapidly, passing through three growth steps (instars) punctuated by moults before becoming fully grown. Typically, large numbers of larvae hatch together and move around the corpse as a group. In doing so, they disseminate bacteria and secrete enzymes which enable them to consume virtually all of the soft tissues of the corpse. Their growth takes several days to several weeks depending upon species, environmental conditions, and the number of larvae present.
Case No. 6
In November a partially clad woman's body was found by passing motorists in a wooded area approximately 50 feet from a well-traveled highway in suburban Washington, DC. The deceased was a young, adult black female, weighing approximately 116 pounds. Her body was cold, rigor mortis was absent, and only minor external decompositional changes were evident. The victim had died of multiple stab wounds to the chest and neck. During the autopsy, several large maggots were observed migrating away from the corpse. This behavior is characteristic of fully developed, post-feeding blow fly larvae. Several additional maggots were removed from the neck wounds and clothing.
The victim was subsequently identified as a 21 year-old mother who resided with her infant and parents in an urban apartment complex in southeast Washington, DC. She had been reported missing by her parents 18 days prior to the discovery of her body. She was last seen alive during the early morning hours on Wednesday, 26 October in the apartment of the primary suspect, who had a history of sex-related offenses and violent crimes and had recently been released from prison.
Witnesses recalled having seen a man and woman struggling and having heard a woman screaming in the vicinity of the apartment house during the early morning hours 18 days prior to her discovery. Hair from the victim's head and pubes was found on bed sheets in the suspect's apartment. A shoe belonging to the deceased was subsequently found in a secluded urban woodlot located a short distance away. Samples of blood and hair taken from the suspect's car also were identified as belonging to the victim. An analysis of auto carpet fibers, removed from the victim's clothing, further demonstrated that she had been transported in the same vehicle.
While considerable circumstantial evidence pointed to the suspect, an accurate estimate of the time of death was critical in establishing the sequence of events surrounding the death. Several conflicting estimates of postmortem interval, varying from 2 to 8 days, were offered by medical examiners and case investigators, based primarily on the physical appearance of the body and the extent to which autolytic changes had occurred within various organs.
The maggots observed in and around the body during the autopsy were identified. Rearing of maggots to the adult stage was not possible as none of the specimens had been maintained alive. Soil samples yielded no additional specimens. Numerous photographs depicting the crime scene, the surrounding vegetation and terrain, and the body itself were examined.
Climatological data, including maximum and minimum temperature, cloud cover, rainfall, wind speed and direction, and relative humidity were obtained from a National Weather Service (NWS) observatory located less than a quarter of a mile from where the victim's body was found. Additionally, reports describing the condition of the body when found and detailing autopsy procedures and results were reviewed.
The largest fly larvae inhabiting the remains were fully engorged third instar larvae and post-feeding larvae of Calliphora vicina. One specimen showed morphological signs of pupariation.
Based on the temperature records for the relevant period, the number of days necessary for Calliphora vicina to develop from egg to prepupa was calculated. Because the average daily temperature to which the developing flies were exposed was cool (10C) and because two few larvae were present within the corpse to elevate microenvironmental temperature, the postmortem interval was estimated to be 15 days.
Based on the entomological data and the other evidence acquired during the police investigation, the suspect was arrested and charged with first degree murder, kidnapping, and felony rape. He was eventually tried, found guilty of all charges, and was sentenced to a lengthy prison term. Later it was learned that he had murdered the victim during the early morning 18 days prior to discovery and had hidden the body, by covering it with tree branches, a mattress, and other debris, in a nearby urban woodlot. Three days later, again during the early morning hours, he had transported the corpse to the location where it was found. The materials used to hide the body may have prevented oviposition by adult Calliphora vicina during the first few days following death. The fifteen day postmortem interval was valid.
Back to the top
Case No. 7
The semi-nude remains of a white male were discovered under a bridge in southern Indiana during the second week of December. The remains showed little decomposition, with only slight skin slippage on the arms and upper torso. A considerable portion of the decendent's face (left side) was skeletonized, postmortem damage caused by rodent feeding. A few calliphorid larvae (Calliphora vomitoria) were found in the exposed sinus and oral cavities of the face.
The remains appeared to have been exposed only a relatively short period of time based upon the physical appearance. In this case, cool temperatures associated with the particular season of the year were important in estimating the approximate time of death. For southern Indiana, temperatures were below average in October, above average in November, and above average in December. Analysis of the blow fly larva development and comparison with climatological data suggested that it would take at least 48 days at the recorded daily maximum and minimum temperatures for the maggots to reach the size and stage found on the remains. When the investigation was completed and the remains identified, it was found that the decedent had wandered away from a mental institution 54 days prior to the discovery of the corpse. The decedent had died from hypothermia and exposure during an October night when temperatures fell well below freezing (24F).
Back to the top
Case No. 8
In the southeastern United States during mid-November, police were called to investigate a foul smelling odor which was emanating from a small single family home in an impoverished section of town. Investigating officers soon discovered the badly decomposed body of a young, black female in a shallow grave in the dirt basement of the dwelling.
The victim had died of a single bullet wound to the head inflicted with a small caliber rifle. Subsequently, a careful examination of the corpse and a detailed excavation of the soil in and around the grave site revealed the presence of numerous larvae of Calliphora vicina and larvae and pupae of a relative of the house fly, Synthesiomyia nudesita.
Specimens collected from the scene were reared in the laboratory. Supplemental information including climatic data and soil temperatures were reviewed in an effort to determine the intervening climatic conditions. Using information on the developmental biology of both of these species of flies, an estimate was made that the victim had died and was colonized by flies approximately 28 days prior to the time of discovery.
Investigators were able to target their investigation in and around the estimated time of death. Shortly thereafter a suspect was identified. This individual eventually confessed to having killed the victim 28 days prior to the time the body was found. She had attempted to bury the victim in a shallow grave located in the basement of the house shortly after committing the homicide.
In this case, larvae of multiple species of flies provided investigators with the only scientifically reliable method of estimating the time of the victim's death.
Back to the top
Case No. 9
Similarly, in early summer, the body of a young, unidentified, white female was found at the end of a logging road in a rural section of the northeastern United States. Investigation revealed that the unidentified young woman had died from a single shotgun blast to the right side of the head. While processing the crime scene, investigators collected representative samples of blow fly adults and maggots infesting the gaping wound.
These specimens proved to be mature larvae and adults of the black blow fly (Phormia regina). Following an in-depth review of climatic conditions, habitat characteristics, and crime scene photographs, entomologists estimated that the young woman had been killed about five days prior to her discovery and that her body had been placed in that location close to the time of her death.
Based in part on the entomological analysis, investigators circulated requests for reports of missing persons fitting the deceased description who had disappeared five days prior to the corpse discovery. Eventually, the young woman was identified and her boyfriend became the prime suspect. Just prior to his arrest, however, he was found hanged in a motel. A suicide note revealed that he had murdered the victim five days before her remains were found and had committed the homicide at the end of the logging road where she was discovered.
Back to the top
Case No. 10
On 26 August, a 37-year old black male was found in Kawainui Marsh, a swamp located approximately 1.6 km from the ocean on the windward side of the island of Oahu, Hawaii. The elevation for the site was only slightly above sea level. The body, clothed in blue jeans and a t-shirt, had a gunshot wound to the right frontal skull.
The corpse was in an advanced state of decay. The skull was largely devoid of flesh, although some was present on the lateral surfaces and the ears were relatively intact. The cervical area was largely devoid of flesh and the vertebrae were clearly visible. The groin area was largely decomposed and contained a large number of Diptera larvae. On autopsy, no penetration of the abdominal cavity by larvae was observed. Collections of insects from the remains yielded 2 species of Calliphoridae larvae. Chrysomya megacephala was represented by 3rd instar larvae from the chest, groin, and legs, while Chrysomya rufifacies was represented by 2nd instar larvae and 3rd instar larvae from the chest. None of the larvae from either species were in the prepuparial stage.
Temperature data were obtained from the nearest weather station, and climatic information from this station was analyzed for the time period in question. This analysis, when coupled with the developmental stages of the specimens collected, suggested a minimum postmortem interval of approximately 117 hours.
A subsequent investigation revealed that the decedent had last been seen at about 6:00 p.m. on 21 August when he departed for work. He failed to arrive at work as scheduled at 8:00 p.m. His remains were discovered on 26 August and were placed into a refrigerated crypt. This species Crufifacies does not form dense maggot masses, activity for this species would have ceased shortly after the remains were placed into the refrigerated crypt. The postmortem interval based on insect age in this case was about 117 hours and fit well with the last sighting of the decedent, and his failure to report for work.
Back to the top
